Match the Bag to the Bin, Not the Other Way Around
The right compostable bag depends on where you collect scraps. A countertop crock, a under-sink bucket, and a tall kitchen bin each call for a different capacity and shape. The supplied records show three distinct options: 1.5-gallon Scrap Sacks, 4-gallon Compostable Food Scrap Bags, and 13-gallon Compostable Tall Kitchen Bags. Below, we break down what each size is designed for and the trade-offs you’ll want to weigh before buying.
One rule applies to all three: they may not be compostable if filled with non-compostable materials. That disclaimer is in each product record, so keep it in mind as you plan what goes in.
Countertop and Small-Batch Collection: Scrap Sacks
- Scrap Sacks: These Full Circle Scrap Sacks come in a package of 10 composting bags that hold up to 1.5 gallons of food scraps. The 1.5-gallon capacity is the smallest in this set, making it a fit for a countertop crock or a small kitchen container rather than a full-size bin.

Scrap Sacks - Scrap Sacks: These composting scrap sacks save space on your counter or in your kitchen compared to other bulky composting bins. If counter space is tight, a small sack-based system can replace a large bin and still keep scraps contained.
- Scrap Sacks: Just keep a sack out to toss your food scraps in and roll down the top and seal it up until it’s filled. The roll-down top gives you a simple way to close the sack between fillings, which helps with smell and neatness.
- Scrap Sacks: They’re easy to use and leakproof. Leakproof construction matters for a bag that may sit on the counter for several days.
What the Scrap Sacks Record Doesn’t Tell You
The record does not state a recommended emptying frequency or a time limit for holding scraps. It also does not confirm whether the sacks are BPI certified or suitable for home composting versus industrial facilities. If those details matter to you, treat them as open questions rather than assuming either way.
Mid-Size Kitchen Scrap Collection: 4-Gallon Food Scrap Bags
- Compostable Food Scrap Bags - 4-Gallon: 100% compostable. This is the clearest compostability claim among the three records, which is useful if you want a bag explicitly described as compostable.

Compostable Food Scrap Bags - 4-Gallon - Compostable Food Scrap Bags - 4-Gallon: Tear & leak resistant. Resistance to tears and leaks is important for a bag that may hold wet food scraps before it’s full.
- Compostable Food Scrap Bags - 4-Gallon: Star seal bottom for maximum strength. The star seal is a construction detail that supports the bag’s strength at the base, where weight and moisture collect.
- Compostable Food Scrap Bags - 4-Gallon: Thicker than the leading plastic brands. Thickness can reduce the chance of punctures from bones or packaging, though the record does not give a micron measurement.
Where the 4-Gallon Bag Fits
The 4-gallon size sits between a countertop sack and a full tall kitchen bag. It suits a medium kitchen container or a household that fills a small bin every few days. The record does not specify a bin shape or rim size, so check your container’s dimensions before relying on a exact fit. Also note the same disclaimer: the bag may not be compostable if filled with non-compostable materials.
Full-Size Kitchen Bin: 13-Gallon Tall Kitchen Bags
- Compostable Tall Kitchen Bags, 13 gal - Unscented: 13-gallon capacity, fits most standard tall kitchen bins. This is the largest option here and is explicitly sized for standard tall kitchen bins, so it’s the choice for a full-size kitchen trash can used for scraps.
- Compostable Tall Kitchen Bags, 13 gal - Unscented: 24” x 27” size. Those dimensions help you check whether the bag will fit your bin’s height and circumference before ordering.
- Compostable Tall Kitchen Bags, 13 gal - Unscented: Super strong drawstring. A drawstring makes it easier to close and carry a full 13-gallon bag without tying knots.
- Compostable Tall Kitchen Bags, 13 gal - Unscented: Triple-ply to prevent leaks. Triple-ply construction is a leak-prevention feature that matters for a large bag holding wet scraps.
- Compostable Tall Kitchen Bags, 13 gal - Unscented: BPI Certified Industrially Compostable (check locally as facilities may not exist in your area). This certification tells you the bag is intended for industrial composting, and the record itself warns that local facilities may not exist.
The Trade-Offs of Going Bigger
A 13-gallon bag holds more scraps, but it also means the bag sits longer before it’s full, which can increase odor and moisture. The record notes the bags are unscented and free of BPA and PFOA, but it does not claim odor control. If you empty your kitchen bin frequently, a smaller bag may be more practical. If you fill a tall bin quickly, the 13-gallon size saves changes.
Also consider end-of-life: the 13-gallon bag is BPI certified for industrial composting, while the 4-gallon bag is described as 100% compostable and the Scrap Sacks record does not state a certification. Your local composting options should guide which claim you can actually use.
Side by Side: Which Size for Which Bin
- Scrap Sacks (1.5 gal): Best for a countertop crock or very small container. Package of 10. Roll-down top and leakproof. No stated certification.
- Compostable Food Scrap Bags (4 gal): Middle ground for a medium kitchen container. Described as 100% compostable, tear and leak resistant, with a star seal bottom. No stated dimensions.
- Compostable Tall Kitchen Bags (13 gal): For standard tall kitchen bins. 24” x 27”, drawstring, triple-ply leak prevention, BPI certified industrially compostable. Unscented.
How to Decide Without Guessing
Measure your bin’s height and opening first. If it’s a countertop container under 2 gallons, the Scrap Sacks are the closest fit. If it’s a medium bin you empty every few days, the 4-gallon bag is the likely match, though you’ll need to confirm the bag’s dimensions yourself because the record doesn’t list them. If it’s a standard tall kitchen bin, the 13-gallon bag’s 24” x 27” size and drawstring are designed for that job.
Finally, remember the shared disclaimer: none of these bags are guaranteed to compost if filled with non-compostable materials. Keep meat, dairy, fats, and pet waste out if your goal is composting, and check with your local facility about what it accepts.



